Shopping for a three-row SUV can feel overwhelming, but Toyota makes it easier by offering two solid choices in the Highlander lineup. The regular gas-powered Highlander gives you more towing power and costs less upfront, while the Highlander Hybrid saves serious money at the pump and comes with all-wheel drive included. Both earn top safety scores and deliver Toyota’s famous reliability.
- Fuel savings: The hybrid gets 35 MPG combined versus 25 MPG for the gas version, saving about $55 monthly on fuel
- Power difference: Gas model makes 265 horsepower and tows 5,000 pounds; hybrid produces 243 horsepower and tows 3,500 pounds
- Price gap: Hybrid costs roughly $2,000 more but includes standard AWD that costs extra on the gas model
Power Under the Hood
The 2025 Highlander runs a 2.4-liter turbo four-cylinder that puts out 265 horsepower and 310 pound-feet of torque. This engine feels strong when you need to merge onto busy highways or pass slower traffic. You can switch between three driving modes depending on your mood; Sport for more zip, Eco to save gas, or Normal for regular driving.
The Highlander Hybrid uses a different setup with a 2.5-liter engine working alongside electric motors for a total of 243 horsepower. That’s less power on paper, but the electric motors kick in instantly, so the hybrid actually feels quick around town. You get extra driving modes too, including EV Mode where you can drive on electricity alone for short distances.
Here’s where the gas version wins big: it can tow up to 5,000 pounds compared to the hybrid’s 3,500-pound limit. If you regularly pull a boat or large trailer, that extra towing muscle matters. The hybrid can still handle most camping trailers and small boats, but you have less wiggle room.
At the Gas Pump
This is where the hybrid really shines. It gets an EPA-estimated 35 MPG no matter if you’re stuck in city traffic or cruising on the freeway. The regular Highlander manages 25 MPG combined – still decent for a three-row SUV, but nowhere near the hybrid’s efficiency.
Let’s talk real money. Drive 15,000 miles a year and the hybrid will save you around $660 annually in gas costs at today’s prices. Over five years, that’s $3,300 in your pocket – enough to cover a big chunk of the hybrid’s higher purchase price.
The standard Highlander gets better mileage with front-wheel drive, but many buyers want all-wheel drive for winter weather or light off-roading. Adding AWD to the gas model drops fuel economy by about 1 MPG.
What You’ll Pay
The 2025 Highlander starts around $40,320, while the Highlander Hybrid begins at $47,770. That looks like a $7,450 difference, but remember the hybrid comes with all-wheel drive standard. Add AWD to the gas Highlander ($1,600 option) and the real gap shrinks to about $5,850.
With annual fuel savings of $660, the hybrid pays for itself in roughly nine years. That might seem like a long stretch, but many people keep their SUVs longer than that. Plus, hybrids typically hold their value better when it’s time to sell or trade.
Both models should have similar maintenance costs over time. Toyota’s hybrid system is proven technology they’ve been refining for decades, so you won’t face scary repair bills. Insurance costs are pretty much the same between the two.
Day-to-Day Life
Both Highlanders seat up to eight people across three rows, though that third row works better for kids than adults. You get the same cargo space in both – 84.3 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
The hybrid does give you something the base gas model doesn’t: standard all-wheel drive. This Electronic On-Demand AWD system automatically sends power to the back wheels when you need extra traction. Great for snowy winters or gravel driveways.
Driving the hybrid feels different in a good way. Around town, it runs whisper-quiet on electric power alone. No engine noise during school pickup or early morning starts. The gas version sounds like, well, a regular SUV – which some people prefer for its familiar feel.
The regular Highlander offers a more traditional driving experience without any learning curve. Fill it with regular gas and go. No worrying about battery life or figuring out hybrid systems.
Tech and Features
Both SUVs come loaded with the same basic tech: 12.3-inch touchscreen, wireless phone connectivity, three-zone climate control, and Toyota’s full safety suite with adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping help.
The hybrid adds some unique displays showing energy flow and efficiency scores to help you maximize gas mileage. The gas XSE model counters with sport suspension for better handling on curvy roads.
Higher trim levels pile on luxury features like heated seats, panoramic sunroof, and premium JBL audio. The equipment lists stay remarkably similar between gas and hybrid versions.
Making Your Choice
The regular Highlander makes sense if you need that extra towing muscle, prefer keeping your upfront costs low, don’t rack up huge mileage each year, or just like the simplicity of a traditional gas engine.
The hybrid works better when fuel savings rank high on your priority list, you want AWD without paying extra, you drive more than 12,000 miles annually, or the quiet electric operation appeals to you.
Either way, you’re getting Toyota’s rock-solid reliability and top safety scores. Your driving habits and budget will point you toward the right choice. Take both for a spin and see which one clicks with how you actually use your SUV.
This post may contain affiliate links. Meaning a commission is given should you decide to make a purchase through these links, at no cost to you. All products shown are researched and tested to give an accurate review for you.